Search icon

4BE-17-00071CI Werba, Alexandra vs. Association of Village Council Presidents NP

Court Case Details

Case Number: 4BE-17-00071CI
Case Type: Civil Superior Ct (4BE)
Case Status: Closed
Action: Other Tort
Case Judge: Peters, Nathaniel
File Date: 28 Feb 2017

Parties

Name Role
Werba, Alexandra Plaintiff
ASSOCIATION OF VILLAGE COUNCIL PRESIDENTS Defendant

Dispositions

Disposition Date Case Judge
Judgment on Pleadings for Plaintiff 2021-03-05 Peters, Nathaniel

Check Data

Date Account Check Amount Description
2021-06-29 0323AN 494659 $24,284.70 Case 4BE-17-00071CI Civil Disbursement to: Guess

Receipts

Receipt Number Date Amount
1383238 2017-03-01 $200.00
1490091 2018-01-30 $5.00
1503833 2018-03-22 $20.00
1590842 2018-12-12 $24,284.70

Events

Date Location Type Result Event Judge
2017-06-05 Courtroom 6, Bethel Courthouse Trial Date Setting Conference Hearing Held Peters, Nathaniel
2018-02-07 Courtroom 6, Bethel Courthouse Oral Argument Hearing Reset Peters, Nathaniel
2018-02-12 Courtroom 6, Bethel Courthouse Oral Argument Hearing Held Peters, Nathaniel
2018-04-19 Courtroom 6, Bethel Courthouse Oral Argument Taken Under Advisement Peters, Nathaniel
2018-05-09 Courtroom 6, Bethel Courthouse Pre-Trial Conference Hearing Vacated Peters, Nathaniel
2018-05-14 Courtroom 6, Bethel Courthouse Jury Trial Hearing Vacated Peters, Nathaniel
2018-05-15 Courtroom 6, Bethel Courthouse Jury Trial Hearing Vacated Peters, Nathaniel
2018-05-16 Courtroom 6, Bethel Courthouse Jury Trial Hearing Vacated Peters, Nathaniel
2018-05-17 Courtroom 6, Bethel Courthouse Jury Trial Hearing Vacated Peters, Nathaniel
2018-05-18 Courtroom 6, Bethel Courthouse Jury Trial Hearing Vacated Peters, Nathaniel

Financial

Cost Type Amount Owned Amount Paid Amount Adjusted Amount Outstanding
Total $225.00 $225.00 $0.00 $0.00
Cost $5.00 $5.00 $0.00 $0.00
Filing Fee $200.00 $200.00 $0.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Revenue $20.00 $20.00 $0.00 $0.00

Docket

Date Text
2018-02-13
                                    Order Granting Motion
            Case Motion #1: Motion to Compel Discovery
                                
2018-02-13
                                    Order Denying Motion
            Case Motion #3: Motion for Reconsideration
                                
2018-11-29
                                    Order Granting Motion
            Case Motion #17: Motion for Attorney's Fees
                                
2018-11-29
                                    Order Granting Motion
            Case Motion #16: Request For Entry of Judgment
                                
2018-02-08
                                    Attorney Information
            Attorney Friedman, Kenneth R representing Plaintiff Werba, Alexandra as of 02/08/2018
                                
2017-02-28
                                    Initial Judicial Assignment: Honorable Nathaniel Peters
                                
2017-02-28
                                    Complaint for Personal Injury and/or Property Damages Not Automobile Related  Receipt: 1383238  Date: 03/01/2017
                                
2017-02-28
                                    Summons and Notice to Both Parties of Judicial Assignment
                                
2017-02-28
                                    Demand Jury Trial
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
                                
2017-02-28
                                    Attorney Information
            Attorney Venneberg, Terry A representing  Plaintiff(s) Werba, Alexandra as of 02/28/2017
                                
2017-05-05
                                    Attorney Information
            Attorney Rankin, Christina representing Defendant Association of Village Council Presidents as of 05/05/2017
                                
2017-05-05
                                    Attorney Information
            Attorney Bergt, Patrick N representing Defendant Association of Village Council Presidents as of 05/05/2017
                                
2017-05-05
                                    Answer
            Association of Village Council Presidents (Defendant);
                                
2017-05-08
                                    Notice of Consent to Service by e-mail
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
                                
2017-05-08
                                    Demand for Jury Trial
            Terry A Venneberg (Attorney) on behalf of Alexandra Werba (Plaintiff)
                                
2017-06-27
                                    Civil Pretrial Order
                                
2017-08-16
                                    Plaintiff's Preliminary Witness List
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
                                
2017-08-16
                                    Defendant's Preliminary Witness List
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
                                
2017-09-14
                                    Stipulation to Extend Time For Expert Disclosure
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Alexandra Werba (Plaintiff); Association of Village Council Presidents (Defendant);
                                
2017-09-28
                                    Notice of Expert Disclosure
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
                                
2017-09-28
                                    Defendant's Disclosure of Use of Experts
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
                                
2017-10-24
                                    Motion to Compel Discovery
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056) 
            Filing Party:  Werba, Alexandra
            Case Motion #1
                                
2017-11-07
                                    Opposition to Motion to Compel Discovery
            Attorney: Bergt, Patrick N (1005008)
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Case Motion #1: Motion to Compel Discovery
                                
2017-11-13
                                    Reply to Opposition to Motion to Compel Discovery
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
            Case Motion #1: Motion to Compel Discovery
                                
2017-11-20
                                    Request For Oral Argument
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Attorney: Bergt, Patrick N (1005008) 
            Filing Party:  Association of Village Council Presidents
            Case Motion #2
                                
2017-11-30
                                    Motion for Reconsideration
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056) 
            Filing Party:  Werba, Alexandra
            Case Motion #3
                                
2017-12-18
                                    AVCP's Motion for Summary Judgment
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Attorney: Bergt, Patrick N (1005008) 
            Filing Party:  Association of Village Council Presidents
            Case Motion #7
                                
2017-12-19
                                    Motion to Strike AVCP's Motion for Summary Judgment
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
            Case Motion #4: AVCP's Motion for Summary Judgment
                                
2017-12-19
                                    Motion for Sanctions
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056) 
            Filing Party:  Werba, Alexandra
            Case Motion #5
                                
2017-12-20
                                    Notice of Withdrawal of Motion To Strike AVCP'S Motion For Summary Judgment And For Sanctions
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
            Case Motion #5: Motion for Sanctions
                                
2018-01-02
                                    Opposition to AVCP's Motion for Summary Judgment
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
            Case Motion #7: AVCP's Motion for Summary Judgment
                                
2018-01-09
                                    Request for Oral Argument
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034) 
            Filing Party:  Association of Village Council Presidents
            Case Motion #6
                                
2018-01-09
                                    AVCP's Reply Regarding Motion for Summary Judgment
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Attorney: Bergt, Patrick N (1005008)
            Case Motion #7: AVCP's Motion for Summary Judgment
                                
2018-01-16
                                    Witness List Filed By: Plaintiff
                                
2018-01-29
                                    Subpoena  Receipt: 1490091  Date: 01/30/2018
                                
2018-02-13
                                    Defendant's Witness List
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Attorney: Bergt, Patrick N (1005008)
                                
2018-02-13
                                    Plaintiff's Final Witness List Filed By:
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
                                
2018-02-23
                                    Notice of Taking Video Deposition
                                
2018-02-26
                                    Attorney Information
            Attorney Valcarce, Jim representing Defendant Association of Village Council Presidents as of 02/26/2018
                                
2018-03-22
                                    CD/Tape Duplication  Receipt: 1503833  Date: 03/22/2018
                                
2018-03-22
                                    Motion to Compel Discovery
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056) 
            Filing Party:  Werba, Alexandra
            Case Motion #8
                                
2018-03-23
                                    AVCP's Supplement To Motion For Summary Judgment
            Attorney: Valcarce, Jim (9505011) 
            Filing Party:  Association of Village Council Presidents
            Case Motion #9
                                
2018-04-02
                                    Motion in Limine RE: Preclusion of Evidence
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056) 
            Filing Party:  Werba, Alexandra
            Case Motion #10
                                
2018-04-02
                                    Opposition to Motion to Compel Discovery
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Attorney: Bergt, Patrick N (1005008)
            Case Motion #8: Motion to Compel Discovery
                                
2018-04-02
                                    AVCP's Motion In Limine to Exclude Evidence RE: Working From Home
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Attorney: Bergt, Patrick N (1005008) 
            Filing Party:  Association of Village Council Presidents
            Case Motion #11
                                
2018-04-02
                                    Defendant's Motion In Limine RE: Future Lost Income and Loss of Earning Capacity
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Attorney: Bergt, Patrick N (1005008) 
            Filing Party:  Association of Village Council Presidents
            Case Motion #12
                                
2018-04-02
                                    Defendant's Motion in Limine RE: Inadmissible Hearsay And Certain Irrelevant Evidence
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Attorney: Bergt, Patrick N (1005008) 
            Filing Party:  Association of Village Council Presidents
            Case Motion #13
                                
2018-04-03
                                    Reply to Opposition to Motion to Compel Discovery
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
            Case Motion #8: Motion to Compel Discovery
                                
2018-04-03
                                    Request For Oral Argument RE: Motion to Compel Discovery
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056) 
            Filing Party:  Werba, Alexandra
            Case Motion #14
                                
2018-04-04
                                    Opposition to Defendant's Motion in Limine RE: Future Lost Income and Loss of Earning Capacity
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
            Case Motion #12: Defendant's Motion In Limine RE: Future Lost Income and Loss of Earning Capacity
                                
2018-04-05
                                    Partial Opposition to Defendant's Motion in Limine RE: Inadmissible Hearsay and Certain Irrrelevant Evidence
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
            Case Motion #13: Defendant's Motion in Limine RE: Inadmissible Hearsay And Certain Irrelevant Evidence
                                
2018-04-09
                                    Opposition to AVCP's Motion In Limine to Exclude Evidence RE: Working From Home
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
            Case Motion #11: AVCP's Motion In Limine to Exclude Evidence RE: Working From Home
                                
2018-04-11
                                    Reply To Opposition To Defendant's Motion in Limine RE: Future Lost Income and Loss of Earning Capacity
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Attorney: Bergt, Patrick N (1005008)
            Case Motion #12: Defendant's Motion In Limine RE: Future Lost Income and Loss of Earning Capacity
                                
2018-04-12
                                    Reply to Partial Opposition to Defendant's Motion in Limine RE: Inadmissible Hearsay and Certain Irrelevant Evidence
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Attorney: Bergt, Patrick N (1005008)
            Case Motion #13: Defendant's Motion in Limine RE: Inadmissible Hearsay And Certain Irrelevant Evidence
                                
2018-04-12
                                    Defendant's Opposition to Motion in Limine RE: Preclusion of Evidence
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Attorney: Bergt, Patrick N (1005008)
            Case Motion #10: Motion in Limine RE: Preclusion of Evidence
                                
2018-04-12
                                    AVCP's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Add Claim For Punitive Damages
            Attorney: Vasquez, Michael A (NA18983)
                                
2018-04-16
                                    Reply To Defendant's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion in Limine RE: Preclusion of Evidence
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
            Case Motion #10: Motion in Limine RE: Preclusion of Evidence
                                
2018-04-16
                                    AVCP's Reply to Opposition to Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence RE: Working From Home
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Attorney: Bergt, Patrick N (1005008)
            Case Motion #11: AVCP's Motion In Limine to Exclude Evidence RE: Working From Home
                                
2018-04-16
                                    Notice of Supplemental Legal Authority In Opposition to AVCP's Motion For Summary Judgment
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
                                
2018-04-16
                                    Plaintiff's Designation of Deposition Testimony
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
                                
2018-04-16
                                    Defendant's Deposition Designations
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
                                
2018-04-23
                                    Defendant's Proposed Jury Instructions
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
                                
2018-04-23
                                    Objections to Defendant's Designation of Deposition Testimony and Plaintiff's Cross-Designation of Deposition Testimony
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
                                
2018-04-23
                                    Plaintiff's Designation of Jury Instructions
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
                                
2018-04-23
                                    AVCP's Objections to Plaintiff's Deposition Designation and Counter-Designations
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
                                
2018-04-25
                                    Order Granting Motion
            Case Motion #7: AVCP's Motion for Summary Judgment
                                
2018-04-26
                                    Objection to Defendant's Designation of Jury Instructions
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
                                
2018-04-26
                                    Defendant's Pretrial Memorandum
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
                                
2018-04-26
                                    AVCP's Objections to Plaintiff's Proposed Jury Instructions
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
                                
2018-04-30
                                    Motion for Reconsideration Of Order Granting Summary Judgment
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056) 
            Filing Party:  Werba, Alexandra
            Case Motion #15
                                
2018-05-01
                                    Notice of filing CD containing Plaintiff's Proposed Jury Instructions
                                
2018-05-09
                                    Invitation For The Defendant To Respond To The Plaintiff's Motion to Reconsider
                                
2018-05-16
                                    AVCP's Response to Motion For Reconsidertaion
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Case Motion #15: Motion for Reconsideration Of Order Granting Summary Judgment
                                
2018-06-26
                                    Order Denying Motion
            Case Motion #15: Motion for Reconsideration Of Order Granting Summary Judgment
                                
2018-07-12
                                    Request For Entry of Judgment
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Attorney: Bergt, Patrick N (1005008) 
            Filing Party:  Association of Village Council Presidents
            Case Motion #16
                                
2018-07-12
                                    Motion for Attorney's Fees
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034) 
            Filing Party:  Association of Village Council Presidents
            Case Motion #17
                                
2018-07-19
                                    Response to AVCP's Motion for Attorney's Fees
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
            Case Motion #17: Motion for Attorney's Fees
                                
2018-07-26
                                    Reply To Response RE: Motion for Attorney's Fees
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Case Motion #17: Motion for Attorney's Fees
                                
2018-12-04
                                    Bill of Costs
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Christina Rankin (Attorney) on behalf of Association of Village Council Presidents (Defendant) 
            Filing Party:  Association of Village Council Presidents
            Case Motion #18
                                
2018-12-11
                                    Objection to Defendant's Bill of Costs
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
            Case Motion #18: Cost Bill
                                
2018-12-11
                                    Reply to Response Re: Cost Bill
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Case Motion #18: Bill of Costs
                                
2018-12-11
                                    Objection to Defendant's Bill of Cost
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
                                
2018-12-12
                                    Civil Deposit Posted  Receipt: 1590842  Date: 12/12/2018
                                
2018-12-12
                                    Motion to Strike Defendant's Bill of Costs
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056) 
            Filing Party:  Werba, Alexandra
            Case Motion #19
                                
2018-12-14
                                    Opposition to Motion
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Case Motion #19: Motion to Strike Defendant's Bill of Costs
                                
2018-12-14
                                    Motion To Stay Enforcement of Judgment Pending Appeal And Motion For Approval of Supersedeas Bond
            Plaintiff, Alexandra Werba 
            Filing Party:  Werba, Alexandra
            Case Motion #20
                                
2018-12-18
                                    Opposition To Motion To Stay Enforcement of Judgment Pending Appeal And Motion For Approval of Supersedeas Bond
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034)
            Case Motion #20: Motion To Stay Enforcement of Judgment Pending Appeal And Motion For Approval of Supersedeas Bond
                                
2018-12-19
                                    Reply To Opposition To Motion to Strike Defendant's Bill of Cost
            Attorney: Venneberg, Terry A (8706056)
                                
2019-01-23
                                    Order Denying Motion
            Case Motion #19: Motion to Strike Defendant's Bill of Costs
                                
2019-01-23
                                    Order Granting Motion
            Case Motion #20: Motion To Stay Enforcement of Judgment Pending Appeal And Motion For Approval of Supersedeas Bond
                                
2019-02-04
                                    Appeal Filed in the Supreme Court Case No: S-17321
                                
2019-02-13
                                    Clerk's Ruling on Cost Bill
            Case Motion #18: Bill of Costs
                                
2019-02-13
                                    Notice of Completion of Preparation of File to Records Management Services
            Appellate Court Case No. S-17321
            certified mail # 7014 2120 0000 0808 1729
                                
2021-03-05
                                    Order Upon Conclusion of Appeal in a Civil Case - Affirmed
                                
2021-03-05
                                    Notice of: Return of Jurisdiction
                                
2021-03-05
                                    Judgment on the Pleadings for Plaintiff
                                
2021-05-04
                                    Defendant's Motion to Release Funds From Court Registry
            Attorney: Rankin, Christina (0306034) 
            Filing Party:  Association of Village Council Presidents
            Case Motion #21
                                
2021-06-14
                                    Order Granting Motion
            Case Motion #21: Defendant's Motion to Release Funds From Court Registry
                                
2021-06-29
                                    Civil Disbursement to: Guess & Rudd PC
                                
2021-07-02
                                    Satisfaction of Judgment