Search icon

3AN-18-07193CI Exxon Mobil Corp et al vs. State of Alaska Department of Revenue EAA

Court Case Details

Case Number: 3AN-18-07193CI
Case Type: Civil Superior Ct (3AN)
Case Status: Closed
Action: Other Superior Court Complaint
Case Judge: Aarseth, Eric A
File Date: 07 Jun 2018

Parties

Name Role
EXXON MOBIL CORPORATION Plaintiff
Hillcorp Alaska LLC Plaintiff
SAExploration, Inc. Plaintiff
State of Alaska Department of Revenue Defendant

Dispositions

Disposition Date Case Judge
Summary Judgment for Defendant 2020-02-04 Aarseth, Eric A

Receipts

Receipt Number Date Amount
1525201 2018-06-07 $250.00
1712211 2020-01-15 $20.00

Events

Date Location Type Result Event Judge
2019-08-21 Courtroom 604, Nesbett Courthouse Trial Call Superior Court Civil Hearing Vacated Aarseth, Eric A
2019-08-28 Courtroom 604, Nesbett Courthouse Trial Call Superior Court Civil Hearing Reset Aarseth, Eric A
2019-09-09 Courtroom 604, Nesbett Courthouse Non-Jury Trial Superior Court Civil Hearing Vacated Aarseth, Eric A
2019-09-09 Courtroom 604, Nesbett Courthouse Oral Argument Taken Under Advisement Aarseth, Eric A

Financial

Cost Type Amount Owned Amount Paid Amount Adjusted Amount Outstanding
Total $270.00 $270.00 $0.00 $0.00
Miscellaneous Revenue $20.00 $20.00 $0.00 $0.00
Filing Fee $250.00 $250.00 $0.00 $0.00

Docket

Date Text
Jun 07 2018
Attorney Information
            Attorney Iversen, Jonathan representing  Plaintiff(s) Hillcorp Alaska LLC as of 06/07/2018
            Hillcorp Alaska LLC (Plaintiff);
Jun 07 2018
Attorney Information
            Attorney Tucker, S Lane representing  Plaintiff(s) Hillcorp Alaska LLC as of 06/07/2018
            
            Hillcorp Alaska LLC (Plaintiff);
Jun 07 2018
Attorney Information
            Attorney Tucker, S Lane representing  Plaintiff(s) Saexploration Inc as of 06/07/2018
            Saexploration Inc (Plaintiff);
Jun 07 2018
Attorney Information
            Attorney Iversen, Jonathan representing  Plaintiff(s) Saexploration Inc as of 06/07/2018
            Saexploration Inc (Plaintiff);
Jun 07 2018
Initial Judicial Assignment: Honorable Eric Aarseth
Jun 07 2018
Superior Court Complaint  Receipt: 1525201  Date: 06/07/2018
Jun 07 2018
Summons and Notice to Both Parties of Judicial Assignment
Jun 07 2018
Attorney Information
            Attorney Iversen, Jonathan representing  Plaintiff(s) Exxon Mobil Corp as of 06/07/2018
            Exxon Mobil Corp (Plaintiff);
Jun 07 2018
Attorney Information
            Attorney Tucker, S Lane representing  Plaintiff(s) Exxon Mobil Corp as of 06/07/2018
            Exxon Mobil Corp (Plaintiff);
Jun 12 2018
Civil Rule 4  Affidavit of Service Upon:
            State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant);
Jul 18 2018
Entry of Appearance
            Katherine Demarest (Attorney) on behalf of State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant); Mary Hunter Gramling (Attorney) on behalf of State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant)
Jul 18 2018
Attorney Information
            Attorney Gramling, Mary Hunter representing Defendant State of Alaska Department of Revenue as of 07/18/2018
Jul 18 2018
Attorney Information
            Attorney Demarest, Katherine representing Defendant State of Alaska Department of Revenue as of 07/18/2018
Jul 18 2018
Answer to Complaint
            Katherine Demarest (Attorney) on behalf of State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant)
Jul 19 2018
Initial Civil Pretrial Order Issued (Anchorage)
            
            Initial Pretrial Order (Anchorage)
            Sent on:  07/19/2018  14:33:43.27
Aug 01 2018
Notice of Joint Submission of Proposed Trial Dates
            Jonathan Iversen (Attorney) on behalf of Exxon Mobil Corp (Plaintiff)
Aug 08 2018
Routine Pretrial Order Issued
Mar 08 2019
Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment
            Attorney: Iversen, Jonathan (0311059)
            Attorney: Tucker, S Lane (0705011)
            Exxon Mobil Corp (Plaintiff); Hillcorp Alaska LLC (Plaintiff); Saexploration Inc (Plaintiff); 
            Filing Party:  Exxon Mobil Corp; Hillcorp Alaska LLC; Saexploration Inc
            Case Motion #1
Mar 12 2019
Notice of Filing Original Affidavit of James Reed
            Jonathan Iversen (Attorney) on behalf of Exxon Mobil Corp (Plaintiff)
Mar 12 2019
Corrected Certificate of Service
            Jonathan Iversen (Attorney) on behalf of Exxon Mobil Corp (Plaintiff)
Mar 14 2019
Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time and Amendment to Routine Pretrial Order  [Frling Opp to Plaintiffs Motion for Summary Judgment 5-10-19;    Reply to States Opposition until 6-14-19;     Amended Final Date to Serve Written Discovery to 5-16-19  And  Amending Final Date to Depose Lay Witnesses to 6-27-19
            Attorney: Gramling, Mary Hunter (1011078)
            State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant); ; Mary Hunter Gramling (Attorney) on behalf of State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant) 
            Filing Party:  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
            Case Motion #2
Mar 18 2019
Notice of Filing Original Affidavit of Mary Hunter Gramling
            Mary Hunter Gramling (Attorney) on behalf of State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant)
Mar 18 2019
Order Granting Motion
            Case Motion #2: Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time and Amendment to Routine Pretrial Order  [Frling Opp to Plaintiffs Motion for Summary Judgment 5-10-19;    Reply to States Opposition until 6-14-19;     Amended Final Date to Serve Written Discovery to 5-16-19  And  Amending Final Date to Depose Lay Witnesses to 6-27-19
Apr 08 2019
Plaintiff's Preliminary Witness List
            Jonathan Iversen (Attorney) on behalf of Exxon Mobil Corp (Plaintiff)
Apr 08 2019
The State of Alaska's Preliminary Witness List
            Mary Hunter Gramling (Attorney) on behalf of State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant)
May 13 2019
Motion to Accept Filings
            Attorney: Ptacin, John M (0412106)
            Attorney: Gramling, Mary Hunter (1011078)
            State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant); 
            Filing Party:  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
            Case Motion #3
May 13 2019
State of Alaska, Department of Revenue's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment 
            Attorney: Ptacin, John M (0412106)
            Attorney: Gramling, Mary Hunter (1011078)
            State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant); 
            Filing Party:  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
            Case Motion #5
May 13 2019
State of Alaska Department of Revenue's Opposition to Plaintiffs' MOtion for Summary Judgment and Memorandum in Support of Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment
            Mary Hunter Gramling (Attorney) on behalf of State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant)
            Case Motion #1: Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment
May 13 2019
Notice of Filing Affidavits With Non-Original Signature
            Mary Hunter Gramling (Attorney) on behalf of State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant)
May 13 2019
State of Alaska, Department of Revenue's Motion to Accept Over-Length Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for summary Judgment and Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment
            Attorney: Gramling, Mary Hunter (1011078)
            Attorney: Ptacin, John M (0412106)
            State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant); 
            Filing Party:  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
            Case Motion #4
May 17 2019
Notice of Filing Original Affidavits of Mary Hunter Gramling
            Attorney: Gramling, Mary Hunter (1011078)
            State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant);
May 17 2019
Plaintiff's Motion to Accept Over-Length Motion for Summary Judgment
            Attorney: Iversen, Jonathan (0311059)
            Exxon Mobil Corp (Plaintiff); Hillcorp Alaska LLC (Plaintiff); Saexploration Inc (Plaintiff); 
            Filing Party:  Exxon Mobil Corp; Hillcorp Alaska LLC; Saexploration Inc
            Case Motion #6
May 17 2019
Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time and Amendment to Routine Pretrial Order [until 07/15/19 to respond to motions #1 +5]
            Attorney: Iversen, Jonathan (0311059)
            Exxon Mobil Corp (Plaintiff); Hillcorp Alaska LLC (Plaintiff); Saexploration Inc (Plaintiff); 
            Filing Party:  Exxon Mobil Corp; Hillcorp Alaska LLC; Saexploration Inc; State of Alaska Department of Revenue
            Case Motion #7
May 22 2019
Order Granting Motion
             
                  Exxon Mobil Corp
             
            Case Motion #7
            Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time and Amendment to Routine Pretrial Order [until 07/15/19 to respond to motions #1 +5]
May 30 2019
Order Granting Motion
             
                  Exxon Mobil Corp
             
            Case Motion #6
            Plaintiff's Motion to Accept Over-Length Motion for Summary Judgment
May 30 2019
Order Granting Motion
             
                  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
             
            Case Motion #3
            Motion to Accept Filings
May 30 2019
Order Granting Motion
             
                  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
             
            Case Motion #4
            State of Alaska, Department of Revenue's Motion to Accept Over-Length Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for summary Judgment and Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment
Jul 15 2019
Opposition to Defendant's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment
            Jonathan Iversen (Attorney) on behalf of Exxon Mobil Corp (Plaintiff)
            Case Motion #5: State of Alaska, Department of Revenue's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment
Jul 15 2019
Unopposed Motion to Accept Over-Length Opposition/ Reply on Summary Judgment
            Attorney: Tucker, S Lane (0705011)
            Exxon Mobil Corp (Plaintiff); 
            Filing Party:  Exxon Mobil Corp
            Case Motion #8
Jul 15 2019
Reply in Support of Plaintiffs Motion for Summary Judgment
            Attorney: Tucker, S Lane (0705011)
            Exxon Mobil Corp (Plaintiff);
            Case Motion #1: Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment
Jul 17 2019
Order Granting Motion
             
                  Exxon Mobil Corp
             
            Case Motion #8
            Unopposed Motion to Accept Over-Length Opposition/ Reply on Summary Judgment
Jul 22 2019
Request for Oral Argument
            Attorney: Ptacin, John M (0412106)
            Attorney: Gramling, Mary Hunter (1011078)
            State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant); 
            Filing Party:  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
            Case Motion #9
Jul 22 2019
State of Alaska, Department of Revenue's Reply to Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendant's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment
            Attorney: Gramling, Mary Hunter (1011078)
            Attorney: Ptacin, John M (0412106)
            State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant);
            Case Motion #5: State of Alaska, Department of Revenue's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment
Jul 23 2019
Calendaring Notice
Jul 24 2019
Request for Oral Argument [Motion #1 and Motion #5]
            Attorney: Tucker, S Lane (0705011)
            Attorney: Iversen, Jonathan (0311059)
            Exxon Mobil Corp (Plaintiff); Hillcorp Alaska LLC (Plaintiff); Saexploration Inc (Plaintiff); 
            Filing Party:  Exxon Mobil Corp; Hillcorp Alaska LLC; Saexploration Inc
            Case Motion #10
Jul 25 2019
Proposed Order Not Used
             
                  Exxon Mobil Corp
             
            Case Motion #10
            Request for Oral Argument [Motion #1 and Motion #5]
Jul 25 2019
Order Granting Motion
             
                  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
             
            Case Motion #9
            Request for Oral Argument
Aug 12 2019
Entry of Appearance
            Patrick Sherry (Attorney) on behalf of State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant)
Aug 12 2019
Attorney Information
            Attorney Sherry, Patrick representing Defendant State of Alaska Department of Revenue as of 08/12/2019
Sep 09 2019
Hearing Findings Taken Under Advisement
            Judge: Aarseth, Eric A (9406020) 
            Filing Party:  Exxon Mobil Corp
            Case Motion #11
Oct 29 2019
Order Denying Motion
             
                  Exxon Mobil Corp
             
            Case Motion #1
            Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment
Oct 29 2019
Order Granting Motion
             
                  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
             
            Case Motion #5
            State of Alaska, Department of Revenue's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment
Oct 29 2019
Order:
             
                  Exxon Mobil Corp
             
            Case Motion #11
            Hearing Findings Taken Under Advisement
Nov 04 2019
Defendant's Motion for Entry of Final Judgment
            Attorney: Gramling, Mary Hunter (1011078)
            State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant); 
            Filing Party:  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
            Case Motion #12
Dec 03 2019
Order Granting Motion
             
                  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
             
            Case Motion #12
            Defendant's Motion for Entry of Final Judgment
Dec 13 2019
Defendant's Motion for Attorneys' Fees and Costs
            Attorney: Gramling, Mary Hunter (1011078)
            State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant); 
            Filing Party:  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
            Case Motion #13
Dec 13 2019
Notice of Filing Affidavit and Cost Bill With Non-Original Signatures
            Mary Hunter Gramling (Attorney) on behalf of State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant)
Dec 13 2019
Cost Bill
            Attorney: Gramling, Mary Hunter (1011078)
            State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant); 
            Filing Party:  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
            Case Motion #14
Dec 23 2019
Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Motion for Fees and Costs
            Attorney: Smith, Connor R (1905046)
            Exxon Mobil Corp (Plaintiff);
            Case Motion #13: Defendant's Motion for Attorneys' Fees and Costs
Dec 23 2019
Notice of Filing Original Affidavit and Cost Bill
            Attorney: Gramling, Mary Hunter (1011078)
            State of Alaska Department of Revenue (Defendant);
Jan 06 2020
Appeal Filed in the Supreme Court Case No: S-17674
Jan 15 2020
CD/Tape Duplication  Receipt: 1712211  Date: 01/15/2020
Feb 04 2020
Order Granting Motion
             
                  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
             
            Case Motion #14
            Cost Bill
Feb 04 2020
Summary Judgment for Defendant Granted
Feb 04 2020
Order Granting Motion
             
                  State of Alaska Department of Revenue
             
            Case Motion #13
            Defendant's Motion for Attorneys' Fees and Costs
Feb 04 2020
Judgment Entered
             
            Judgment Amount:                     0.00  
            Pre-Judgment Interest:             0.00  
            Attorney Fees:                        14,577.00  
            Court Costs:                                39.20  
            Other Fees:                                   0.00  
            Judgment Total:                     14,616.20  
            Total Accrued Costs:                  0.00  
            Total Accrued Interest:               0.00  
            
            Terms: 5.25% 
            
            Type: Judgment 
            Judge: Aarseth, Eric A 
            Judgment Date: 02/04/2020 
            Judgment Time: 12:00PM 
            Referee:  
            Recommendation Date:  
            
            Judgment Status: Judgment Entered 
             
            Judgment For: State of Alaska Department of Revenue - Defendant 
             
            Judgment Against: Exxon Mobil Corp - Plaintiff 
             
                                                ------------------------------------------- 
                                                Issuance 
                                                ------------------------------------------- 
                                                Writ Type:  
                                                Date Issued:  
                                                Accrued Interest:  
                                                Satisfied Amount:  
             
                                                ------------------------------------------- 
                                                Return 
                                                ------------------------------------------- 
                                                Processed By:  
                                                Received From:  
                                                Accrued Costs:     
                                                Satisfied Amount:  
                                                Date Returned:  
                                                Date Collected:  
                                                Date Paid:  
             
                              Hillcorp Alaska LLC - Plaintiff 
             
                                                ------------------------------------------- 
                                                Issuance 
                                                ------------------------------------------- 
                                                Writ Type:  
                                                Date Issued:  
                                                Accrued Interest:  
                                                Satisfied Amount:  
             
                                                ------------------------------------------- 
                                                Return 
                                                ------------------------------------------- 
                                                Processed By:  
                                                Received From:  
                                                Accrued Costs:     
                                                Satisfied Amount:  
                                                Date Returned:  
                                                Date Collected:  
                                                Date Paid:  
             
                              Saexploration Inc - Plaintiff 
             
                                                ------------------------------------------- 
                                                Issuance 
                                                ------------------------------------------- 
                                                Writ Type:  
                                                Date Issued:  
                                                Accrued Interest:  
                                                Satisfied Amount:  
             
                                                ------------------------------------------- 
                                                Return 
                                                ------------------------------------------- 
                                                Processed By:  
                                                Received From:  
                                                Accrued Costs:     
                                                Satisfied Amount:  
                                                Date Returned:  
                                                Date Collected:  
                                                Date Paid:  
             
            Judgment Satisfied Amount:             0.00  
            Judgment Balance:                         14,616.20  
            Case Total:                                          0.00  
            Case Satisfied Amount:                    0.00  
            Case Balance:                                     0.00
Jun 30 2021
Order Upon Conclusion of Appeal in a Civil Case - AFFIRMED